representing_work_done

Template:— representing_work_done (rep_wrk_done)
Capability:representing_work_done

Date: 2008/01/18 08:58:19
Revision: 1.30

Cover Contents Description Model diags.Input params.Ref. params.Instantiation path Instance diags.Characterizations Issues in situ

Issue raised against: representing_work_done

GENERAL issues

Issue: GYL-1 by Leif Gyllstrom (2007-05-04) major_technical issue
Resolution: Reject. Status: closed

This template has a huge overlap with the template representing_activity_actual. Suggestion is either to delete this template or a least reuse the more generic template ! To be honest I think it should be deleted and instead describe this area in the capability along with how the more generic template can be used to represent this.

Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-11-18)
The templates should stay as there is a real difference between: - authorized work done to a product, Template_ref name="representing_work_done" capability="representing_activity" - activities performed by a product, Template_ref name="representing_product_usage" capability="representing_activity" - and activities that have occurred with not authorized directed_activity Template_ref name="representing_activity_actual" capability="representing_activity". The introduction to all three templates have been reworded to explain the differences.

Issue: RBN-1 by Rob Bodington (07-10-31) minor_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

The uniqueness constraint "Unique constraint: External id class" should be called "Unique activity actual"

Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-10-31)
Addressed

Issue: EPM-RI-13 by JH, EPMT (2007-12-5) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: D:\users\rbn\projects\010937_DNV_dexlib\docs\review\\EPM reviews\template_issues_EPMT_JH.xls Template: representing_work_done Check list clause: 6 XML >figure ..< tags do not include a "master"-attribute with a reference to an editable file (source file).

Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-11-18)
corrected

Issue: EPM-RI-14 by JH, EPMT (2007-12-5) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: D:\users\rbn\projects\010937_DNV_dexlib\docs\review\\EPM reviews\template_issues_EPMT_JH.xls Template: representing_work_done Check list clause: 8 There are editable (source) files (under 'dvlp'), but not all of the same name as each figure file provided (under 'images').

Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-11-18)
Corrected

Issue: EPM-RI-15 by JH, EPMT (2007-12-5) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: D:\users\rbn\projects\010937_DNV_dexlib\docs\review\\EPM reviews\template_issues_EPMT_JH.xls Template: representing_work_done Check list clause: 9 Not "Instatiate activity_actual", but "Instantiate activity_actual". Not "Repair breakes", but "Repair brakes". Not "Break repair method", but "Brake repair method". Not ' /IGNORE', but '/IGNORE'(no leading blank) in instantiation path.

Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-11-18)
Corrected

Issue: EPM- by , (undefined) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: D:\users\rbn\projects\010937_DNV_dexlib\docs\review\\EPM reviews\template_issues_EPMT_JH.xls Template: Check list clause: Not "can can", but "can".

Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-11-18)
Corrected

Issue: EPM-RI-16 by JH, EPMT (2007-12-5) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: D:\users\rbn\projects\010937_DNV_dexlib\docs\review\\EPM reviews\template_issues_EPMT_JH.xls Template: representing_work_done Check list clause: 15 There are references to Stepmod modules: links in Reference Parameters point into stepmod modules, e.g., "Allow the >Person< entity ..."; same in Instantiation Path.

Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-11-18)
This is allowable and an XSLT issue

Issue: EPM-RI-17 by JH, EPMT (2007-12-5) major_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: D:\users\rbn\projects\010937_DNV_dexlib\docs\review\\EPM reviews\template_issues_EPMT_JH.xls Template: representing_work_done Check list clause: 17 Seems to have an overlap with template representing_activity_actual (see RI-19).

Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-11-18)
See GYL-1

Issue: EPM-RI-18 by JH, EPMT (2007-12-5) major_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: D:\users\rbn\projects\010937_DNV_dexlib\docs\review\\EPM reviews\template_issues_EPMT_JH.xls Template: representing_work_done Check list clause: 21 There is 1 major issue recorded against this template: GYL-01.

Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-11-18)
See GYL-1

Issue: EPM-RI-19 by JH, EPMT (2007-12-5) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: D:\users\rbn\projects\010937_DNV_dexlib\docs\review\\EPM reviews\template_issues_EPMT_JH.xls Template: representing_work_done Check list clause: 24 The term "directed activity" is used, and few people know this.

Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-11-18)
rephrased introduction

Issue: EPM-RI-20 by JH, EPMT (2007-12-5) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: D:\users\rbn\projects\010937_DNV_dexlib\docs\review\\EPM reviews\template_issues_EPMT_JH.xls Template: representing_work_done Check list clause: 28 The EXPRESS-G diagram contains templates that are additional characterization * which I think is good.

Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-11-18)
The convention is that there should be a separate characterization diagram showing the optional templates. this has been added.

Issue: EPM-RI-21 by JH, EPMT (2007-12-5) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: D:\users\rbn\projects\010937_DNV_dexlib\docs\review\\EPM reviews\template_issues_EPMT_JH.xls Template: representing_work_done Check list clause: 29 date_class_name and date_ecl_id are missing as blue text in the diagram.

Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-11-18)

Issue: EPM-RI-22 by JH, EPMT (2007-12-5) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: D:\users\rbn\projects\010937_DNV_dexlib\docs\review\\EPM reviews\template_issues_EPMT_JH.xls Template: representing_work_done Check list clause: 30 The items-parameter should possibly be prefixed by the template name.

Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-11-18)
Corrected

Issue: EPM-RI-23 by JH, EPMT (2007-12-5) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: D:\users\rbn\projects\010937_DNV_dexlib\docs\review\\EPM reviews\template_issues_EPMT_JH.xls Template: representing_work_done Check list clause: 42 The abbreviated graphical template representation is missing.

Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-11-18)
added

Issue: EPM-RI-24 by JH, EPMT (2007-12-5) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: D:\users\rbn\projects\010937_DNV_dexlib\docs\review\\EPM reviews\template_issues_EPMT_JH.xls Template: representing_work_done Check list clause: 46 The abbreviation repr is used instead of rep.

Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-11-18)
Changed diagram and short_name

Issue: EPM-RI-25 by JH, EPMT (2007-12-5) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: D:\users\rbn\projects\010937_DNV_dexlib\docs\review\\EPM reviews\template_issues_EPMT_JH.xls Template: representing_work_done Check list clause: 61 The optional templates in the Express-G are not in the instantiation path.

Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-11-18)
They should not be - they are characterizations

Issue: EPM-RI-26 by JH, EPMT (2007-12-5) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: D:\users\rbn\projects\010937_DNV_dexlib\docs\review\\EPM reviews\template_issues_EPMT_JH.xls Template: representing_work_done Check list clause: 65 At least some are not in the plcs_registered.owl, but in plcs-proposed.owl .

Comment: (Rob Bodington 08-01-02)
All classes are present

Issue: EPM-RI-27 by JH, EPMT (2007-12-5) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: D:\users\rbn\projects\010937_DNV_dexlib\docs\review\\EPM reviews\template_issues_EPMT_JH.xls Template: representing_work_done Check list clause: 73 Reference data used to provide a meaningful example have other URN but 'urn:plcs:rdl:sample' .

Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-11-18)
The correct URN has been used urn:plcs:rdl:std

Issue: EPM-RI-28 by JH, EPMT (2007-12-5) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: D:\users\rbn\projects\010937_DNV_dexlib\docs\review\\EPM reviews\template_issues_EPMT_JH.xls Template: representing_work_done Check list clause: 77, 82 The textual example is missing some of the values, such as id_class_name for @2.

Comment: (Trisha Rollo 07-12-31)
Missing data added

Issue: EPM-RI-29 by JH, EPMT (2007-12-5) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: D:\users\rbn\projects\010937_DNV_dexlib\docs\review\\EPM reviews\template_issues_EPMT_JH.xls Template: representing_work_done Check list clause: 87 For one the textual example is repeated here. For the other, the layout of the P21-file is unfortunate and makes reading it difficult.

Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-11-18)
Corrected P21 layout

Issue: EPM-RI-30 by JH, EPMT (2007-12-5) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: D:\users\rbn\projects\010937_DNV_dexlib\docs\review\\EPM reviews\template_issues_EPMT_JH.xls Template: representing_work_done Check list clause: 88 The uniqueness constraint has the title "External id class", but should have "Activity actual" or the like.

Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-11-18)
It has "Unique activity actual"

Issue: EPM-RI-31 by JH, EPMT (2007-12-5) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: D:\users\rbn\projects\010937_DNV_dexlib\docs\review\\EPM reviews\template_issues_EPMT_JH.xls Template: representing_work_done Check list clause: 89 The unique entities defined, are not referenced by a reference parameter.

Comment: (Rob Bodington 07-11-18)
The unique entity is Activity_actual which is referenced by %^actual_work = Activity_actual%

Issue: EPM-RI-32 by JH, EPMT (2007-12-5) editorial issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Issue file: D:\users\rbn\projects\010937_DNV_dexlib\docs\review\\EPM reviews\template_issues_EPMT_JH.xls Template: representing_work_done Check list clause: 90 For one, entity instances are displayed that are not part of this template; for the other, items not origiating in this template are not embedded into a grey area.

Comment: (Trisha Rollo 07-12-31)
corrected