Capability (C094):— assigning_organization Date: 2009/02/11 09:52:20
Revision: 1.40

Issue raised against: assigning_organization

GENERAL issues


Open issue Issue: DNV-05 by Sylvia Schwab on behalf of DNV (07-02-27) major_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

There is no template for relating an organization to another organization. Currently the entity Organization_relationship is only present in C016 Representing_person_organization.

Proposal: NEW Template called "asg_org_rel" (assigning_organization_relationship): The template describes the relationship between two organizations classified using assigning_reference_data.

The OASIS cap C094 assigning_organization doesn't include the entity Organization_relationship therefore we suggest to add this to C094 and add a new template for the relationship."

Comment: (Peter Bergström 2007-05-24)
The only reason to create a template for the relationship is to make the classification of the relationship clearly visible, but it might not be necessary? We would get very many templates if we did this for every relationship... It should however be clearly described in the Capability.


Open issue Issue: DNV-5a by Sylvia Schwab on behalf of DNV (07-02-27) major_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

This issue is related to the proposal of the new template assigning_organization_relationship and this template to be part of assigning_organization capability (C094) instead of representing_person_organization (C016).

Should the name of the capability be changed to representing_organization with one template called assigning_organization and the new template called representing_person_organization


Open issue Issue: DNV-5b by Sylvia Schwab on behalf of DNV (07-02-27) major_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: open

This issue is related to the proposal of a new template assigning_organization_relationship to be part of assigning_organization.

The capability assigning_organization (C094) doesn't include the entity Organization_relationship (currently only available as part of representing_person_organization). The entity needs to be added to the capability in order to be able to add the new template.

Comment: (Peter Bergström 2007-05-24)
I agree, regardless if we have a new template or not the Capability must deal with the relationship.

GENERAL issues


Closed issue Issue: RBN-1 by Rob Bodington (05-06-24) minor_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

An address can be associated with an organization by address_assignment (PDM schema approach) or by using location_assignment to assign a location that has a representation that is a postal address. I think that we should advocate one approach and given that the location approach allows more that just an address, we should recommend that approach. Should this be documented in assigning_organization or representing_location? I was also wondering whether we needed a new capability representing_organization to describe relationship between organizations. Or should that be in assigning_organization as well?
Comment: (Rob Bodington 06-06-21)
The capability now specifies the use of assigning_location.


Closed issue Issue: RBN-2 by Rob Bodington (05-09-21) minor_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

The assigning_classified_identification template should be moved from assigning_organization to assigning_identifiers capability. The template can then used to identify things where the organization that "owns" the identifier is not known, or is not important. The template should be renamed to: assigning_identification_with_no_organization
Comment: (Rob Bodington 05-11-18)
assigning_classified_identification renamed to assigning_identification_with_no_organization and moved to assigning_identifiers capability


Closed issue Issue: RBN-3 by Rob Bodington (05-09-21) minor_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

We need to consistently use /IGNORE
Comment: (Rob Bodington 06-06-26)
Updated


Closed issue Issue: GYL-1 by Leif Gyllstrom (05-09-21) minor_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Capability number shall be C094 (not just 94).


Closed issue Issue: RBN-4 by Rob Bodington (05-10-26) minor_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

The EPXRESS-G diagram "Figure 5 An EXPRESS-G representation of the Information model for assigning_organization" shows some optional characterization. This should be described in the characterization section of the template.
Comment: (Rob Bodington 05-10-26)
Updated


Closed issue Issue: NN-1 by Nigel Newling (05-11-17) minor_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Should assigning_identifiers be a dependent capability.
Comment: (Rob Bodington 06-06-21)
Yes - this capability requires the use of the template assigning_identification_with_no_organization which is defined in the capability assigning_identifiers


Closed issue Issue: DNV-7 by Sylvia Schwab on behalf of DNV (07-02-27) major_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Templates such as assigning_approving_organization need to reference an organization (similiar assigning_approving_person need to reference person_in_organization). Organization should be represented independently and referenced.

Proposal: NEW Template called "repr_org" (representing_organization): The template describes an organization when its only role is its existence without an entity approving_person_organization. This makes it easier to relate organizations to an organization hierarchy or e.g. approving_person_organization.

The template consists of the entity organization with the assigned templates as described in assigning_approving_organization as well as an optional assigning_address .

Comment: (Peter Bergström 2007-05-24)
This is a good idea, since there are entities whose attributes refer to Organization, see for example template assigning_approval.
Comment: (Rob Bodington 08-02-15)
A new template representing_organization has been created.


Closed issue Issue: RBN-5 by Rob Bodington (07-08-09) minor_technical issue
Resolution: Accept. Status: closed

Moved template assigning_organization_relationship to NDLO/template