Help TOC > Instructions for DEX developers > Reviewing > Capability Review Template
Capability Review Template Date: 2008/03/03 21:33:07
Revision: 1.10

Instructions

This checklist is intended to provide quality assessment criteria for the development of OASIS/PLCS DEX standards. It shall be completed by the assigned reviewers and then presented to the PLCS Technical Oversight Group in OASIS for a ballot review prior to submitting the CapabilityA description of how EXPRESS entities are used to represent a given concept (a specific "functionality" or "capability"). It provides guidance and rules on what Entities should be used to represent a given concept, how the entities should be related, and what Reference Data should be used. As well as general guidance, a set of Templates are documented within a Capability to provide precise specifications of which Entities should be instantiated to represent identified concepts. for OASIS ballot...

The review activity is a part of the capability development process .

How to use this Template

To be decided...

How to use the Review Checklist

The data modeller shall check items marked "(M)". Business domain experts shall check items marked "(B)". Either may check items marked "(E)".

Answer each question by setting the status to:

If a question is answered "NA", explain the reason why the question is not applicable in the comment field.

If a question is answered "NO", an issue should be raised against the capability in DEXlib. Each issue should be identified as "RI-X-nnn-v", where "X" is the section in the Review Checklist, "nnn" is the section number, and "v" a version number (1,2,3,...) to be used if "NO" is answered to the same review question ore than once. Add the issue identifier to comment field. In cases where the Business domain expert can't access DEXlib as a developer, the model reviewer should assist the Business domain expert.

Review Checklist

Data

This review is made against the following Capability,
Capability id:
CVS version:

Review was performed by:
Modeller:
Domain expert:

Checklist completed:

Review form

Section A - General

Item 001 (M)
Status: NR
Question: Is the status of the Capability according to the Capability Development Process set to "end_modelling"?
Comment: (no comment)

Item 002 (M)
Status: NR
Question: Are the names of the project leader, editor, model reviewer and business reviewer documented in the capability and in accordance with the OASIS PLCS resource matrix?
Comment: (no comment)

Section B - Figures

Item 001 (M)
Status: NR
Question: Are all figures in the "png" format?
Comment: (no comment)

Item 002 (M)
Status: NR
Question: Are all images stored in a folder named "images"?
Comment: (no comment)

Item 003 (B)
Status: NR
Question: Are all figures sequentially numbered?
Comment: (no comment)